Blogging About Critters Since 2007

Showing posts with label alberta. Show all posts
Showing posts with label alberta. Show all posts

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Catholic Bishop Says Animals to be "Used"

I came across this letter in the CalgaryHerald written by Fred Henry, Roman Catholic Bishop of Calgary. I can't tell if it's an Op-Ed or a letter, but it doesn't really matter.

He irritated me. As a former Roman Catholic myself, I don't mind saying it either.

He was writing in response to the outcry in the animal rights community over the Canadian seal hunt.

He focuses specifically on PETA and Sea Shepherd, Jeremy Bentham and Peter Singer, and seems to overlook the broad range of outrage in the world. And he starts hitting below the belt.

Regrettably, most of the parties seem to be on parallel tracks and there isn't much chance of them finding common ground until all the parties begin to address the social movement which parades under the heading of "animal rights."

Parades under the heading of "animal rights?"

Oh, but it gets better. Then he brings in abortion and stem cell research and calls into question Ingrid Newkirk's pro-choice position.

And here's the kicker.

"Animals are God's creatures. He surrounds them with his providential care. By their mere existence they bless him and give him glory. Thus men owe them kindness. God entrusted animals to the stewardship of those whom he created in his own image. Hence it is legitimate to use animals for food and clothing. They may be domesticated to help man in his work and leisure. Medical and scientific experimentation on animals is a morally acceptable practice if it remains within reasonable limits and contributes to caring for or saving human lives.

"It is contrary to human dignity to cause animals to suffer or die needlessly. It is likewise unworthy to spend money on them that should as a priority go to the relief of human misery. One can love animals; one should not direct to them the affection due only to persons."

While we are called to respect all creation and must use it wisely, the key is "we can use it."


So we shouldn't show animals affection the way we show it to humans? Even though some animals may show certain people more love and acceptance than the humans in their lives? And don't give money to animal causes? I don't think that animal causes are swimming in money. There is plenty of money out there for human causes; in fact, the vast majority goes there. The problems contributing to human misery are derived from global economics and geopolitics. The small amount of money for animal causes is hurting no one.

Besides, there are so many things to talk about when it comes to the Catholic Church. I am an atheist so I don't believe that somehow a God came along and told humans to use animals. We evolved into a predator species and we did it naturally. Because we can communicate, read and write, we can control information and design a society where we can justify our "use" of species. WE made that decision. Not a non-existent God. And, even if there were a God, I still don't believe that this point has been made clear to anyone.

History belongs to the victor. We are the victors in this case, at least for now. So, Bishop Henry, it doesn't surprise me that you will find any argument possible that will elevate your species and justify its "use" of others. The Catholic Church has done that so many times before, with other human groups, and "paraded" itself as speaking the word of God.

(By the way, Bishop Henry, tell me again why can't women be priests? Aren't all humans equally above animals?)

Monday, November 26, 2007

Canadian Hunting May Be Hurting Polar Bears

I didn't even know Canada had hunting policies for polar bear. It's amazing what one learns from running a blog. Anyway, not only are polar bears in danger of drowning from melting ice caps, but their male population is threatened by hunting. Because it takes two to reproduce, this hunting could endanger the survival of the species.

Here are the highlights....

New research suggests that Canadian polar bear hunting policies could be pushing populations of the iconic Arctic predator toward sudden, steep declines.

Hunters focus mostly on male bears. {Peter Molnar of the University of Alberta} said that about two-thirds of the bears taken by hunters in Canada are males.

That means the bears could be edging toward what biologists call the Allee effect - a sudden collapse of breeding success after the male-female ratio passes a tipping point.

Scientists say two-thirds of the world's polar bears will be gone by 2050 as melting sea ice slowly robs them of their habitat.

Animal rights activists such as the U.S. Humane Society have used those statements to argue for a ban on sport-hunting. The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service is currently considering declaring the bears an endangered species, even though the lowest estimate of their worldwide population is 20,000.

But Inuit, who can earn up to $30,000 for guiding a single sport-hunting trip, say bear numbers are healthy and some populations are actually growing - testimony often referenced by climate change skeptics.

The report was done in collaboration with the government of Nunavut. Although polar bear quotas are proposed by community-based hunter's groups, the territory has the ultimate responsibility for deciding how many of the bears can be taken.


Photo by intrepidberkeleyexplorer.

Sunday, November 11, 2007

Deplorable Conditions at Alberta Roadside Zoos

Two Alberta, Canada roadside zoos are being accused of serious violations of animal welfare and are currently under investigation.

(Is there ever a GOOD roadside zoo? These things should be banned as far as I'm concerned.)

Fish and Wildlife officers are looking into allegations of filthy drinking water, rotting carcasses in cages and animals going "insane" from boredom, levelled at Discovery Wildlife Park near Innisfail, and at Guzoo Animal Farm near Three Hills.

"The reports are already being sent out to our field staff, who will go through the allegations and respond where needed," said Darcy Whiteside, a spokesman for Alberta Sustainable Resources.

But representatives with Zoocheck Canada and the World Society for the Protection of Animals said Wednesday the province is to blame for the deplorable conditions and public safety issues at the attractions.

They blame the government for failing to enforce zoo regulations.

"Each day, the government dwindles on enforcing its own rules," said Melissa Tkachyk, a spokeswoman for the World Society for the Protection of Animals. "Alberta needs to clean up or close down these roadside zoos."


Apparently, Alberta has some of the best zoo regulations in Canada, but it doesn't enforce them. Meanwhile, the accused zoos are calling the same old fouls...those darn people out of Ontario are trying to tell them what to do, goshdarnit!

The zoos' owners defended their attractions Wednesday and said they were tired of responding to "self-proclaimed animal activists out of Ontario."

"We are licensed by the government according to development plans approved by the province," said Lynne Gustafson, who has operated Guzoo for 18 years.

"We can't get a permit if we don't pass inspections."

Meanwhile, there were 50 violations at Discovery Wildlife Park, she said.

But Doug Bos, who owns the facility -- widely known as the place visitors can pay to kiss a bear -- said inspections have become more frequent.

"Things are a lot tighter than they were before," said Bos, who has roughly 100 animals and has been operating for 20 years.

Photo by jomoud.
blog stats